How to Identify and Handle Fraudulent Shopify Orders
Fraudulent orders cost Shopify brands money, time, and chargeback risk. Here is how to identify fraud before it ships, handle it when it happens, and build systems to minimize it.
Step-by-Step Guide
1Use Shopify's built-in fraud analysis
Shopify flags orders with risk indicators — mismatched billing/shipping addresses, multiple orders on different cards from the same IP, and other signals. Review all high-risk orders before fulfillment. Never ship a high-risk order without manual review.
2Watch for these fraud signals
Multiple orders to different shipping addresses using the same card, orders for high-value items with express shipping to freight forwarders, billing addresses in one country with shipping to another, and orders placed with multiple failed card attempts before success.
3Use a fraud prevention app
Shopify's built-in risk detection is a starting point, not a complete solution. Apps like NoFraud, Signifyd, and Kount provide more sophisticated fraud detection — and many offer chargeback protection guarantees for orders they approve.
4Have a clear process for cancelling suspected fraud
When you cancel a suspected fraud order: (1) cancel before fulfillment if possible, (2) send the customer a cancellation email asking them to contact you if the order was legitimate, (3) issue a refund immediately, (4) document the signals that triggered the cancellation.
5Handle friendly fraud separately
Friendly fraud — a legitimate customer claiming non-delivery or 'not as described' to get a free product — is more common and harder to detect than criminal fraud. The best defense: tracking confirmation, delivery confirmation, and complete order documentation.
6Review your chargeback reason codes for fraud patterns
Chargeback reason code '10.4' (card not present fraud) indicates criminal fraud patterns. Frequent 10.4 chargebacks signal you need stronger fraud prevention. '13.1' (merchandise not received) often indicates friendly fraud requiring better delivery documentation.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I know if an order is fraud without being wrong?
No fraud detection is perfect. The goal is to balance fraud prevention with legitimate order acceptance. Tools like Signifyd provide chargeback guarantees — if they approve an order that turns out to be fraudulent, they cover the chargeback.
Should I cancel orders I think are fraudulent without contacting the customer?
Yes, in most cases. Contacting the customer gives fraudsters warning to dispute before you can cancel. Cancel the order, issue a refund, and send a non-specific cancellation email. Legitimate customers will reach out.
Let Opsio handle this for your Shopify brand
Stop managing ops tasks yourself. Opsio's pre-trained team handles everything covered in this guide — and more.
Get Started Today